Some Pros:
- Students will come in knowing what to expect procedurally.
- Students will be eager to enter the classroom and settle in in order to watch the video (provided I succeed in finding videos that are both entertaining and education-oriented).
- While students watch the video, their attention will be fixed on the screen, releasing me from the need to supervise as directly as I would otherwise and allowing me the freedom to handle a variety of administrative tasks that are best addressed early in the class period.
- I can connect the short lessons that I will provide to the students to the video I have chosen. (For example, I'm planning to show a clip from an Obama-McCain debate in which they argue their perspectives on US military policy. I would connect this with our current chapter on Athens and Sparta to show how Obama-McCain compare with Athens-Sparta in the sense that they show a cosmopolitan and hawkish perspective on war, respectively).
- I can teach a wider range of communication skills by covering video, film, music, etc. with a metacognitive approach, rather than just relying on written words and my own speech.
- I can provide concrete visual connections to those students who have trouble comprehending the abstraction of our written texts.
- Class may be just a smidge more fun.
- I can say more in my lesson by talking less (I think my students will greatly appreciate this aspect).
Some Cons:
- Students may not be as interested or invested as I anticipate in starting each class with a video.
- Students may be too distracted in watching the video to pay attention to the work I have assigned to guide them.
- Students may interpret the use of video as a license to switch into a passive mode of thinking rather than engaging with the material in a way that they might with a written text.
- Students may be distracted by the video and miss out on the more important aspects of the connections between the video and our learning objectives.
I'm sure there is a lot more downside than I'm anticipating at present. But, I'm eager to get started with this idea so I can see exactly what will work and what won't.
Does anyone else have some ideas about what I could be missing?
Link to the video I'm considering for the example I gave on Obama-McCain as Athens-Sparta.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.metacafe.com/watch/1801738/mccain_obama_face_off_on_iraq_war/